PDA

View Full Version : Phil Wright Sensei ~ Final comments



Damien_lucifer
18th August 2007, 08:22 PM
well ok, here's the final piece from Phil Wright Sensei, enjoy.


" Final Notes for Damien. Plus Epilogue. (Written as open, to Forum.)

What we must do now is, conclude the Kendo politics. You’ve had some egotism on the Internet, and had a good run of emailing and such things. You even had someone called Steve Bishop (?) replying to you, claiming that, along with others like him, he has been instrumental in imposing a totalitarian coaching regime on a whole Kendo association! His assumed justification for that gross discourtesy being, he claims… it’s his day job! Imposing his profession on all dojo leaders in Britain? And upon Kendo - an ancient Japanese art? Because he thinks it’s ‘his job’ to do so? We’re thankful he isn’t a chef; the BKA becoming a chain of burger restaurants? But it’s not our job, to listen to him. Nor to obey him, or other ‘jobbers.’
A Kendo wisdom exists: “You must not give up your career, for Kendo.”

As I always tell my students, Kendo is a study in two parts… The Ken. And the Do. And each of those two parts, are in themselves, independent studies of many other parts, abilities, and self attributes.
But, before any Kendo occurs, there’s one aspect of Kendo that we must not forget. A truth that can always take us out of silly politics, dispelling any intrusive rules and regs that may ever be imposed upon us…
So many Japanese people fought, suffered and died to perfect the system of swordsmanship we know as Kendo, that Japanese Kendo authority can never be successfully plagiarized. It would be a total absurdity for any nation other than Japan, to claim to hold the franchise of Kendo authority.
That doesn’t mean we all have to become Japanese! Nor do we have to give up any of our national identity. But, we do have to give up elements of ourselves that are oafen. And respect the courage, of those who created Kendo. And part of the acknowledgement of that past Kendo courage, is to refuse to surrender to present day Kendo politicians. The oafen people, (or frightened little boys) who believe that they’re the authority of Kendo.

I’ve practised Kendo long enough, in an ideal Kendo UK, to be 9th dan.
At my level, Kendo is a clerical (moral) study. The basis of the morality of Kendo is, the same as the other m/arts, which is firstly, physical self control. From that physical element of self authority, develops the mental self authority we know as morality. Or in other words: The physical self development, of Ken. And the mental self development, of Do.
The real authority of Kendo is, yourself. (You have to be, just yourself.)
The self respect you have, as a Kendoka. (You have to respect yourself.)
A Kendo wisdom: One way of defending your self respect is, to laugh at those who irritate you. Coaching Kendo is copying a Sensei, or someone great. Like jumping up, shouting, “I’m Spartacus!” To teach Kendo, you have to fight, and a Sensei impose the duties of being a Sensei, upon you.

Our Hatamoto Dojo (the Will Adams Kendo Club) is in Gillingham, in the UK, a town twinned with the towns of Ito and Yokosuka, in Japan.
The petty new rules and regs of the BKA politicians might soon make it impossible for us to hold Kendo sessions in the sports centre we’re based in. Or ‘officially’ anywhere else. But, that doesn’t mean we have to give up Kendo. Who needs ‘officers,’ like kendo traffic wardens, anyway?
All we do is walk over to the common land, and practise in the open. Or find some private venue; a beer garden, or someone’s garden maybe? In the past, I’ve run seminars sailing up the River Thames in big cruisers… all leaping out of the boats to do Kendo in parks and beer gardens. Ha!
Nowadays our seminar/holiday weeks are on beaches, plus formal dojo.

Our dojo may be viewed by some, as being the choteki (the rebels).
But really, and sadly for British Kendo, the truth is the exact opposite...
We are not so much being loyal, to Kendo. We are always that, anyway.
Our protest is, we refuse to be loyal, to those who are disloyal to Kendo.

Phil Wright. Hatamoto Dojo.
Post Script:
If there ever comes a day when a man walks into my dojo and says, “I’m a moral man; (hence a worthy opponent) I challenge you for your dojo.” And his Kendo is so good it could only be deemed that he’d defeated me. And if he would attend regularly to teach my students, I would surrender my dojo, gladly, and walk away. That process is an honourable tradition.
But, there is something I don’t know… A concept I wonder about, but I can’t understand, or even imagine. But, perhaps someone reading this in the WK Forum can tell me..? What does it take? What depths must a soul be dredged to? What compromises must a human mind make? And what amount of fears (of phantoms?) must be felt? How much perplexity, self pity and self doubt must there be? What appalling levels of cowardice in a ‘man’ and lack of shame in his dojo? For a Kendo teacher to surrender his dojo (his personal autonomous authority) to an authoritative myth of Kendo, that’s as valid as the myth of Santa Claus?

As far as I know, if you do a phone search for Kendo, in any directory in the UK, you’ll still only get one phone number. It won’t be Santa Claus’s. It will be mine. That’s because… I am Spartacus! Ha!
If you haven’t got the guile of Kendo, you haven’t yet found happiness.
“Strive to be happy.” Democritus. 5th c. BC.

If you’re now laughing, I’m winning. If you’re now angry, I’m winning.
(And if you’re now coaching, I hope you arrive at the seaside, safely.)

August 15th 2007. Epilogue: From Phil Wright. Hatamoto Dojo.
I’m impressed. Whoever runs the World Kendo Forum internet thing, is a free spirit, and has much courage. And understands a lot about Kendo.
My greatest respects to you. And thanks for your help. I will explain…
Damien, a large, powerful, highly intelligent man, with a great sense of humour, passed his 6th kyu grading tonight. The Internet banter, was just a project for him, as a study of the Do, of Kendo. He only did it, because he knew he could. But I knew that the political doughnuts and drop outs would crawl out of the woodwork. And we could all look at their ideas.
Yes, I’ve made mistakes, teaching people not intelligent enough to study Kendo. By example: In the early 1980s I was horrified by the amount of prejudice against the Japanese (and Kendo) in Gillingham. It was awful! I didn’t understand what was really going on, until a guy named Tadashi Makino, then Chairman of the Ito Tourist Association wrote a book about his research of Will Adams, “The Blue-eyed Samurai.” He was Japan’s senior representative, twinning our towns. In his book, he frankly states, that Gillingham is the last place on Earth any Japanese tourist should ever visit! He was looking for where Will Adams lived. Later I discovered the Gillingham Council knew where Will Adams had lived, but didn’t admit it, because there was to be a ‘Unitarian’ council. Against public opinion. Gillingham, being taken over by a university property development com. was not to have more unique character, such as a sword saint. But, at the time, I didn’t realize that, and just responded to what I saw as prejudice:
I began to write a Kendo thesis by which people interested in Oriental studies, could come to terms with the differences between our cultures. So I created a study theme: Catabasics. : Confucianism and Taoism, also Buddhism and Shintoism, in Christian Societies.
Every nation has its common Christ elements. And nations believing in evolution, advances of morality and social ethic, use the Christ icon, as a medium of describing a person capable of bringing about such evolution. Miyamoto Musashi was such a sword Christ personality, for the Japanese. There is, therefore, an onus when studying advanced Kendo, in the UK, to compare the theologies, and their origins, of the Christs of two nations.
The boast of unis is, that they teach a universe of info. But, do they.?..
You’ve read the silly claim, that I demanded to be acknowledged as the Messiah, by one of my drop out university drop ins. And there has been comment that I’m insane. Ha! I could say, “it’s all lies.” But the truth is much simpler than that. I mentioned to a student I was writing Catabasics. Not an academic, the only way he got into a uni was on a pottery course. My mistake. I should not mention the Do (theology) of Kendo to people who will never understand it. I’m not Jesus. Nor am I Hannibal Lector.
But, I am a humorous writer. I entertain the readers, and my students.

But some people, will always moan, about everything! (And Gami did.) Anyone reading garden gnome culture, such as Harry Potter, or Lord of the Rings, which are in the tradition of the kagamishin - the mirrors and jewels culture - instead of The Book of Five Rings, could never possibly agree with my Kendo, anyway.

For me, Damien achieved a total success. He has served his dojo well…
Catabasics 1983 became a very publishable book by 1986. Rewritten four times, the final edition is almost finished. I know I’ve got a brilliant best seller. It’s clever, interesting, and very funny. Publication is no problem. Loads of money! Build a huge dojo! A Kendo cathedral! But, authority has a problem. People who’ve known me, could claim that what they do, is what I’ve taught them. But now due to WK Forum, readers (and Japan) know I’m nothing what so ever to do with any UK university kagamishin. Nor am I responsible for anything even remotely like it, anywhere. Thank you for publication, especially ‘adverse’ opinion… A good result for me. For my dojo. And for my book.

Phil Wright. Hatamoto dojo."

kartoffelngeist
18th August 2007, 08:55 PM
You know, when you first posted this dude's stuff, I thought it was quite cool. The second one made him seem a bit odd. This one I didn't even bother reading after he said he should be 9th dan.

Take people's advice...

A Wadlow
19th August 2007, 07:17 AM
Never have I seen so many words actually say so little. I even botherd to scan through the other threads you started with these ramblings.

Have some neg rep as i'm feeling generous

samurai80
19th August 2007, 08:51 AM
So thats it?

Damien, is there opinions of your own you wish to express, or are his opinions automatically yours now?

While he sounds like a nutjob sometimes, I have to admit that he raises questions in my mind like...

1.What is the real deal between BKA and this sensei? I've heard things here and there, but can I get a simple answer?

2.Why do I keep having to read 1000 words or more about something that could have been summed up in three or four sentences?

3.What is the point of these posts?

4.Does Damien actually say anything, or is he just this guy's messenger/bitch(as Ignatz put so delicately)? If he is just the messenger, is the ancient rule of "don't kill the messenger" still in effect, or is killing appropriate in this situation?

5. Was there ever life on Mars?

Kenshi
19th August 2007, 05:49 PM
My 1 question would have to be this:

6. Why did someone with such breadth of knowledge in kendo call his club "Hatamoto Dojo" ... ?

ben
19th August 2007, 06:31 PM
I also have a rhetorical question to ask: what is the bug he's got up his arse about coaching? Australian kendo has had a nationally integrated, and government-recognised coaching accreditation program since the 1980s. In a population as small and geographically dispersed as Australia, this more than any one factor was the reason kendo was able to develop the way it has, with uniformly high standards of practice whether you're in Western Australia or Wollongong. We have often been commended by visiting Japanese sensei such as Fukumoto Shuji that it is unusual to find in countries outside Japan the situation where it is not just the two most populous states or areas who dominate, but that nearly all attending states are competitive and have a chance of winning. This is the result of the work done 25 years ago to create a uniform method of measuring andd developing coaching quality. And if anyone thinks this is not the 'traditional' way, the man who is largely to thank for this system is an 87 year old Japanese 7-dan.

b

Kendoka_Han
19th August 2007, 09:58 PM
Extract from Phil Wright sensei:

At my level, Kendo is a clerical (moral) study. The basis of the morality of Kendo is, the same as the other m/arts, which is firstly, physical self control. From that physical element of self authority, develops the mental self authority we know as morality. Or in other words: The physical self development, of Ken. And the mental self development, of Do.
The real authority of Kendo is, yourself. (You have to be, just yourself.)
The self respect you have, as a Kendoka. (You have to respect yourself.)
A Kendo wisdom: One way of defending your self respect is, to laugh at those who irritate you. Coaching Kendo is copying a Sensei, or someone great. Like jumping up, shouting, “I’m Spartacus!” To teach Kendo, you have to fight, and a Sensei impose the duties of being a Sensei, upon you.


This was really something awesome to read.

Mr. T.
20th August 2007, 01:02 AM
You know, this Phil Wright thing makes me sick. I really don't like the fact that the BKA's dirty laundry is there for every one to see. This is an internal thing, not a Kendo World thing. If your sensei (or you) has a problem with the way things are done in the UK, He has to solve it with the BKA, EKF, FIK or any other kendo authority. The man may be a bit of a nut (sorry but that's how I think of folks who believe they are 9th dan without showing any proof), but if he's really want to do this the Japanese way, he should solve this internally and not let one of his students post his very confusing rants on the net for the world to see...:mad:

So do me a favour and keep this crap of KWF and let your sensei battle it out with the BKA behind closed doors. This isn't good for the BKA's rep. and kendo in general. Your sensei says he doesn't like the politics, but in the mean time he's playing the (political) game very public. If he doesn't want to be involved with the politics or the coaching thing, he should shut up and teach and nothing else.

I'm done and very disapointed in you Damian for letting yourself being used like this and in your sensei for playing this game in the open :(

Lady_Kitsune
20th August 2007, 01:41 AM
Just a couple of questions...9th dan? Does he know anything about kendo at all?

samurai80
20th August 2007, 04:19 AM
9th dan is obtainable. (rare)

Neil Gendzwill
20th August 2007, 04:42 AM
Not any more.

Lady_Kitsune
20th August 2007, 04:53 AM
That's what I knew... 8th dan is the final

samurai80
20th August 2007, 06:42 AM
My bad, I was under the impression that 9th dan was sort of a honorary title, where as 10th dan is no longer obtainable.

A Wadlow
20th August 2007, 08:01 AM
I don't understand, why is this still up? It lets down this forum that threads of grotty porn get deleted faster than something that some mentalist has given to some looser (Yes, to be honest damien is a looser, we know it and he definatly knows it) to spread accross KW.

And if it doesn't get deleted I'm starting Your Mum jokes on it untill it does.

PORN>DRIVEL


I'm assuming that as its flames I can saw what I want... so I will

Mokujin77
20th August 2007, 09:55 AM
I'm not even going to get involved about the content of these...well, I suppose you could call them diatribes, but I will say this - the punctuation sucks something awful.

ZtefaNNN[K]
20th August 2007, 10:47 AM
This guy is seriously delusional

Fudo-Shin
20th August 2007, 04:02 PM
[edit] It lets down this forum that threads of grotty porn get deleted faster than something that some mentalist has given to some looser [edit]Yeah I agree, people are way too hard on the porn! :smiley:

Ok seriously, I think if Phil Wright Sensei really has to pick the bone publicly like this, which I don't see why for the same reasons Mr. T and others mentioned, he should at least be doing it himself. Not through Damien. I think Damien is unsuspecting in this.

Damien, have you thought about your own reputation? At some stage you will have to grade/compete/partake in Kendo at other Dojo where people from this forum will know exactly who you are. It may affect you in those scenarios without even knowing it, until it dawns on you years later why you didn't make that grade etc etc.

Damien_lucifer
20th August 2007, 05:33 PM
Damien, have you thought about your own reputation? At some stage you will have to grade/compete/partake in Kendo at other Dojo where people from this forum will know exactly who you are. It may affect you in those scenarios without even knowing it, until it dawns on you years later why you didn't make that grade etc etc.


sorry, are you suggesting that a grading could be affected by what's written on a forum and not by the quality of my kendo?



at the end of the day, im not out to impress any of you on here, i mearly am here to practise and firther my knowledge of kendo. if during this my sensei wants me to post a couple of things on the net for him, then why shouldn't I?

the amount of posts i have heard with the words "listen to your sensei", is that not what im doing?

if or when the time comes to "grade/compete/partake in Kendo at other Dojo where people from this forum will know exactly who you are" then so be it. but i will be there for kendo and not for light conversation about the latest post on the forum.

Damien_lucifer
20th August 2007, 05:39 PM
So thats it?

Damien, is there opinions of your own you wish to express, or are his opinions automatically yours now?

While he sounds like a nutjob sometimes, I have to admit that he raises questions in my mind like...

1.What is the real deal between BKA and this sensei? I've heard things here and there, but can I get a simple answer?

2.Why do I keep having to read 1000 words or more about something that could have been summed up in three or four sentences?

3.What is the point of these posts?

4.Does Damien actually say anything, or is he just this guy's messenger/bitch(as Ignatz put so delicately)? If he is just the messenger, is the ancient rule of "don't kill the messenger" still in effect, or is killing appropriate in this situation?

5. Was there ever life on Mars?


i don't think im advanced enough, in my own opinion, to add seriously to discusions concerning kendo.

Q's 1-3 are not for me to answer

Q 4 purley messenger

Q 5 probally, An examination of a meteorite found in Antarctica and probally to be from Mars shows; 1/ hydrocarbons which are the same as breakdown products of dead micro-organisms on Earth. 2/ mineral phases consistent with by-products of bacterial activity, and 3/ tiny carbonate globules which may be microfossils of the primitive bacteria, all within a few hundred-thousandths of an inch of each other. all of which could point to tawards previous life on mars

bobdonny
20th August 2007, 05:54 PM
sorry, are you suggesting that a grading could be affected by what's written on a forum and not by the quality of my kendo?.

Damien, how you do kendo is the same as how you live your life (and that includes posting on forums). Of course its a reflection on your personality, and a reflection on how you do kendo. Be it good or bad.

At this stage be pragmatic, forget about who is right or wrong, and just back out and let the sensei's deal with it theirselves if they must, getting involved in politics at a junior level is garanteed to make you forget why you started / do kendo.

A Wadlow
20th August 2007, 05:54 PM
Q's 1-3 are not for me to answer



Yeah its also not for you to splash over kendo world, you know nothing about the BKA or any of its politics past or pressent. Now stop posting crap.

Damien_lucifer
20th August 2007, 05:56 PM
Yeah its also not for you to splash over kendo world, you know nothing about the BKA or any of its politics past or pressent. Now stop posting crap.

im just following what my sensei has asked me to do.

you were under no obligation to read this post, but there may be some who want to.

the thread was clearly marked as to who it pertained to.

A Wadlow
20th August 2007, 06:04 PM
im just following what my sensei has asked me to do.


Surely you must have some mind of your own? If he said "sniff this" and offered his finger you wouldn't would you? So why post stuff about an organisation you don't know about, are you aware that there is the slightest chance it is biased or even possibly untrue?

JSchmidt
20th August 2007, 07:15 PM
the amount of posts i have heard with the words "listen to your sensei", is that not what im doing?

Listen to your teacher, but don't stop using your brain!.

Fudo-Shin
20th August 2007, 07:28 PM
sorry, are you suggesting that a grading could be affected by what's written on a forum and not by the quality of my kendo?I was talking about worst case scenarios and I simply used that as an extreme example, I only said that in passing and I'm not making any dire predictions for you. However it's not un-heard of (but I won't go there), I would like to think it doesn't exist too. Hopefully nothing like that ever happens to you but sometimes things happen and it makes people biased, even highly ranked Sensei.

I think you have balls for doing what you have done and I respect your integrity towards your Sensei. I simply wonder/worry what possible outcomes this could have for you though. Do you think anything positive will come out of this?

One thing I do know for sure is that, Kendo politics can become very sticky, very quickly and it can directly/indirectly effect innocent people who didn't really aim to be involved in the 1st place. In turn that can have implications that may come in 1 or more of many different forms. I sincerely hope nothing negative will manifest itself towards you because of this, just trying to give you some perspective.

shred_lord
20th August 2007, 07:28 PM
I don't think Damien would be held be from grades. That simply not the way things work. However, he not going to make many friends.

dwez
20th August 2007, 08:26 PM
I think you have balls for doing what you have done and I respect your integrity towards your Sensei.

No, Owen had balls, he too spouted a lot of crap [he'll proabably agree], respected his kung fu sensei but when he went loony at least he had the brains to say 'that's not right' and had the balls to give up his long term martial art for something not so opinionated. I have new found respect for Owen based on these posts.

Fudo-Shin
20th August 2007, 08:39 PM
I think you have balls for doing what you have done and I respect your integrity towards your Sensei.

No, Owen had balls, he too spouted a lot of crap [he'll proabably agree], respected his kung fu sensei but when he went loony at least he had the brains to say 'that's not right' and had the balls to give up his long term martial art for something not so opinionated. I have new found respect for Owen based on these posts.So what do you think Damien should do? I don't see how the 2 are related.

JSchmidt
20th August 2007, 08:49 PM
So what do you think Damien should do? I don't see how the 2 are related.

I think he should just do kendo and stop being Mr. Wrights mouthpiece. I'm sure Mr. Wright is capable of posting here himself.

PhilMcLaughlin
20th August 2007, 08:59 PM
A couple of points

Phil Wrights ramblings speak for themselves, Hes a nice enough guy at a personal level, relatively harmless but definitely not on the same planet as the rest of us

However,

- He is in a minority of 1 on just about every issue he raised

- The coaching scheme is partly designed to protect impressionable people from themselves, go figure.

- DL's biggest crime is in being very loyal to a man who demands loyalty. Its very cult like & I found it disturbing to say the least (and thats 25 years ago)

- You very rarely see Phils students at BKA events, why is that ?

The BKA isnt that political really. Yes there are issues , its an orgnaisation of people & people by nature tend to have politics. There ARE ways of raising issues in house

For those out there who have got the impression that BKA is out to get Phil, thats wrong. Phil is his own victim.
Its just a shame his students get such a poor return for their investment

last point to Damien

You have a brain, you're not a kid. I suggest you engage it, look at the posts you've had from Kendo all round the world and think this one out for yourself

regards

Phil..

Fudo-Shin
20th August 2007, 09:28 PM
I think he should just do kendo and stop being Mr. Wrights mouthpiece. I'm sure Mr. Wright is capable of posting here himself.Couldn't agree more.

dwez
20th August 2007, 10:46 PM
So what do you think Damien should do? I don't see how the 2 are related.

The majority of folks have figured out what he should do. DL should respect his sensei if that is what he whishes but should be able to make his own mind up about mindlessly requrgitating his sensei beliefs, which up until this point he hadn't. Something Owen did, that's how they are related. DL's recent posts amounted to just words by his sensei. He admits now he can't answer half the questions people have posed based on what his sensei has said. Surely this is good enough reason not have posted on his behalf.

I should imagine by this stage DL has made up his mind, but it would seem he is in the majority of one. I guess he has got balls, he should have a +rep. I certainly wouldn't be posting messages for my sensei without being able to answer queries about what I was posting. As has been said before, 'what is the point of that'?